Response to Hi, David. The NorthStar Pump shaft seal is based on when the unit was manufactured or when the impeller as replaced. This Pump Shaft Seal - SPX3200SA is the other option since P/N SPX1600Z2 did not work. Return instructions will be emailed to you. 

An image is worth 1,000 words! Add an image or two to your comment to help ensure it is understood accurately.

Yes, please email me exclusive discounts, swimming pool tips and helpful how to guides. This comment may be posted on a public site. Do not include: HTML, references to other retailers, pricing, personal information, or any profane, inflammatory language.